[simpleton]

Random acts of context

December 15, 1997
New Ones Monday through Friday

News You Can Lose

How to do civic journalism on the cheap


One thing everybody claims to agree on is the inadequacy of the six o'clock news. Just when Americans are clamoring for more context, for reporting on the relevant issues that impact their communities, both TV and print media are becoming more random, violent and sensationalistic than ever:

[the bloody body was found covered with blood]


But there are good reasons to be content with the idea of news as a series of disconnected puddles of blood. It is possible to provide focused, intelligent coverage of news that effects the community. Unfortunately, even when it's interesting, this kind of news is boring:

[I'll see your two freeholders and raise you one comptroller]


A more serious problem is that context, in reporting terms, usually just means tacking a few paragraphs from previous stories to the back of the current story. You provide context by attributing one event to some other event that everybody knows about anyway. If somebody goes off welfare, it's because of tough new welfare regulations. If somebody else gets shot in an argument, it must be the breakdown of civility in our society.

[poulet folle!]


Context is especially troublesome when it concerns foreign countries; attempting to provide context is what turned CNN into a talk show mall, instead of the ceaseless parade of flag-draped coffins, random shelling and food riots it should be. Where foreign affairs are concerned, the principle is that macro-events demand macro-explanations. Here's one of the motivations the New York Times provided for the growing popularity of Halloween in France:

[in france, recession = costumes and candy]


Stagnant economies can even explain events in countries other than the countries with the stagnant economies. Want to know why the tourist economy is so hot in Mallorca?

[germans love the sun!]


And best of all, this game has no rules. Another news story I saw recently explained why Greece's tourist trade hasn't been so hot lately:

[but sometimes they don't]


Since a stagnant economy can explain both the good news and the bad news, I'm hoping Germany's economy recovers soon, allowing the coverage to come full circle:

[sometimes the economy's good, and sometimes it isn't]


And that's all the news for today. Go out there and get the story. Then explain what it all means.

Analyze the news for us.







Previously in simpleton:



Friday: Feeb: Biting the hand that Feeds us
Thursday: How to be an American: A simpleton civics guide
Wednesday: Reader Mail: Volume 10
Tuesday: On the Vanity of Innovation The Simpleton moves into the 18th Century
Monday: Can This Meat Kill You? The new strain of food infections
Friday: A Guide to Romance: Why an obscure Canadian student is the sexiest man alive!


A century of simpletons in the simpleton archive.


Tomorrow:

A universal language